Better Than the Hanukkah Bush
It's the time of year when the city erupts in red, green, and gold, and if you're Jewish, that can leave you feeling a little left out. Christmas carols spill out of every storefront while we hum along to "Hanukkah, Oh Hanukkah" in a minor key. Somewhere in that gap, the hanukkah bush was born.
If you've never heard the term, you're not alone in wondering whether such a thing is even real. It is, sort of, and the story says a lot about Jewish life in America.
Is a Hanukkah Bush Even a Thing?
Yes, informally. A hanukkah bush is a real, recognizable idea, though it has no basis in Jewish law or historical tradition. The term hanukkah bush dates back to 1879, so American Jews have joked about, debated, and occasionally decorated one for well over a century.
A hanukkah bush, sometimes spelled chanukah bush or hannukah bush, is essentially a christmas tree rebranded for Hanukkah. Some families dress it in blue and white lights. Others hang a Jewish star, a dreidel, or other Jewish symbols right alongside the colored balls, a jewish christmas tree of sorts.
For many families, the hanukkah bush becomes a focal point for winter festivity, a christmas tree in the living room that says "we're celebrating too."
Still, most rabbis today do not encourage the practice. A christmas tree is traditionally associated with the celebration of Jesus' birth, rooted in christian traditions and christian themed decorations tied to European customs. A decorated tree carries that history, and many traditional rabbis feel it sits uneasily next to wonderful jewish holidays like Hanukkah, rooted firmly in Jewish history.
The Great Debate: Assimilation or Just a Fun Tradition?
The hanukkah bush emerged primarily in the mid-to-late 20th century in North America, when jewish families navigated real cultural pressure from the dominant christmas season. Store windows and school parties all pointed one direction, not toward the jewish calendar.
Some Jews view the chanukah bush as an act of cultural assimilation, a quiet blending of non jewish rituals into jewish holidays. Others see it as a fun tradition, a way to combat christmas envy without giving up any piece of jewish identity.
This tension even made national news, when a hanukkah bush and menorah display dispute at the South Dakota capitol became a talking point about representing minority faiths during the holiday season.
Community debate around the hanukkah bush reflects bigger questions about assimilation and belonging. Many jewish families oppose hanukkah bushes for resembling other christmas trees too closely. Some Reform rabbis, though, support hanukkah bushes as a personal choice, no different from any other holiday decoration, including artificial hanukkah bushes.
The children's book There's No Such Thing as a Chanukah Bush, Sandy Goldstein by Susan Sussman captures this exact tension through a young Jewish girl who wants what her non-Jewish friends have. It remains a favorite children's book for parents explaining why their own hanukkah celebrations might look different from a neighbor's christmas tree.
Even Saturday Night Live joined in with Hanukkah Harry, the wise grandfather figure who saves the holiday when Santa gets stuck in a chimney. The actor behind the bit has an Emmy Award to his name from decades of sketch comedy, proof "hanukkah man" jokes have staying power. There is even a novelty christmas song or two written from a Jewish kid's perspective, a sign christmas envy is a shared, not secret, experience.
How Jewish Families Actually Celebrate Hanukkah
For every family with a hannukah bush in the corner, many lean into Hanukkah's own fun traditions instead.
Hanukkah commemorates the rededication of the Second Temple and the miracle of the oil that was only supposed to last one night but burned for eight. That is why Hanukkah runs for eight nights, and why food fried in oil, like latkes and sufganiyot, anchors most Hanukkah tables.
Making latkes and sufganiyot together is a beloved evening activity. Setting up a dreidel tournament is another favorite, since kids love small gifts wagered on each spin, along with new clothes given throughout the holiday. Many jewish parents invite friends to visit friends and family for at least one night, mixing food, games, and candle lighting into an evening full of holiday activities.
Creating window decorations to publicize lighting the Hanukkah candles is an old practice, tied to the mitzvah of pirsumei nisa, publicizing the miracle, by placing the menorah where passersby can see it. It is a quiet counterpart to a neighbor's christmas eve display, using your own lit window to tell a similar story. A white orchid or a blue and white arrangement like Cerulean on the same sill makes the glow even brighter.
Discussing Jewish history with children using ritual items, a dreidel, a menorah, a bowl of matzah ball soup like Uncle Max always makes, is one of the simplest ways families pass the holiday down. Many families enjoy reminiscing about past Hanukkahs while lighting candles, the same way other households enjoy reminiscing over a christmas tree and family pictures.
One quick clarification: a hanukkah bush is not the burning bush from Jewish history. The burning bush is the biblical story of Moses in Exodus, symbolizing God's enduring presence, that faith and the Jewish people continue on without being consumed. It has nothing to do with holiday trees; it is a separate, older symbol from the jewish calendar's founding stories.
And if you're wondering what year Hanukkah "skips," it doesn't. Hanukkah follows the Hebrew lunar calendar, which doesn't line up with the secular year, so its start date shifts on the Gregorian calendar every year. In rare years it falls unusually early, which is likely why some people mistakenly think a year gets skipped, but every Jewish calendar year gets its full eight nights.
As for what to say instead of "Happy Hanukkah," many Jewish people use Chag Sameach, "happy holiday," or the more specific Chag Urim Sameach, "happy festival of lights," both warm alternatives to a simple greeting.
PlantShed Picks for a Blue and White Hanukkah
Skip the knock-off tree. These living alternatives bring Hanukkah's colors home and last well past the eighth night.
Blue and White Flowers
- Sapphire: White and blue hydrangeas, blue delphinium, white calla lilies, roses, and lisianthus in a blue glass vase. A showstopper for the table where you light the menorah.
- Cerulean: White hydrangeas, white roses, blue delphinium, and eryngium in a blue cube vase. Crisp, compact, and easy to fit on a windowsill or side table.
- Blue Diamonds: Blue delphiniums and white lisianthus with ornamental kale and bupleurum. A cool, wintry arrangement that makes a great hostess gift for a latke party.
- Arctic Bouquet: White roses, lisianthus, thistle, and blue hydrangeas, hand-tied and ready for your own vase.
The Hanukkah Orchid
- White Phalaenopsis Orchid in Aqua Basket: A white orchid in a blue-toned woven basket, Hanukkah colors in a plant that blooms for weeks. For a smaller gift, try the Mini White Phalaenopsis Orchid in Aqua Basket.
- 3-Stem White Phalaenopsis in Glass: Standing 27 to 30 inches tall, a dramatic statement for the entryway or the holiday table. Browse more orchid plants for every space.
Plants That Outlast the Holiday
- Ponytail Palm: The original "Jurassic Hanukkah" pick, with long curly leaves and a bulbous trunk. Low-maintenance and a great choice for pet parents.
- Verge Crystal Succulent Garden: Mixed succulents planted alongside an amethyst crystal in a cream-glazed pot. A gift that keeps growing long after the candles burn down.
- Luna Succulent Bowl Large: Lush rosettes and upright succulents in a Luna ceramic bowl with decorative stones, a nod to the "Hipster Hanukkah" succulents from our original list. See all cacti and succulents.
Bringing the Season Home, PlantShed Style
Whether your family embraces a hanukkah bush, skips it entirely, or lands in between with a few david tree toppers and some blue and white ribbon, the holiday season is really about the same thing for jewish families and everyone else: light, warmth, and time with people you love.
If you want something for your own window decorations or your own hanukkah celebrations that isn't a stand-in christmas tree, PlantShed can help. A pop of blue and white blooms or simple seasonal greenery can do the same job as a decorated tree, without the direct comparisons to other christmas trees people put up to celebrate christmas down the block. It is a lovely way to mark the holiday and make the apartment feel festive, no identity crisis required.
However you choose to celebrate, from latkes to a hanukkah bush to no tree at all, happy Hanukkah from all of us at PlantShed. Stop by one of our NYC shops this season for flowers and plants that fit whatever version of the christmas holiday and Hanukkah your family loves best.